|
THE
CONNECTION BETWEEN DEPRESSION, ADDICTION, & HYPOGLYCEMIA
By
Jurriaan Plesman BA(Psych), Post Grad Dip Clin Nutr
There is very little in the scientific literature that spells out the
connection between depression, drug addiction and hypoglycemia. The reason
seems to be that the hypoglycemia is as yet not recognized
by mainstream medicine as a classifiable illness, despite the fact that
many health practitioners agree that it is the forerunner of diabetes.
It is difficult to investigate a non-existent disease. The term hypoglycemia
does not show up in any search of Medline, except when mentioned in connection
with diabetes.
Another reason is that the term hypoglycemia is a misnomer
and is bound to confuse many medical practitioners who understand the
term to mean quite correctly low blood glucose levels. A more
appropriate term would have been dysglycemia, indicating unstable
blood glucose concentrations often seen in a Glucose Tolerance Test of
people having hypoglycemic symptoms. Again dysglycemia
does not show up in any Medline search. Because early literature on hypoglycemia
concentrated on the low levels of blood sugar as the cause
of symptoms, the expression has stuck as hypoglycemia.
The third reason may well be that over the last fifty years medical research
has been dominated by commercial corporations - such as international
pharmaceutical companies, instead of independent universities - driven
by motives of profits and answerable only to investors, instead of community
interests. Hypoglycemia can be treated by dietary and lifestyle changes,
thus attracting little attention to commercial corporations and their
clients.
In the absence of solid research data we are left with a theoretical approach
to the understanding of what the connection is between hypoglycemia and
depression and drug addiction.
The serotonin/sugar addiction hypothesis
Some scientists believe that sugar addiction (sucrophilia) is due to an
error in the metabolism of serotonin. Scientists have noticed that many
drug addicts have a history of sugar addiction (Burton, 485-488) and they
believe that this is due to a dysfunction in serotonin synthesis.
Serotonin is a neurotransmitter that conveys the sensation of satiety
or satisfaction - like a happy hormone. It is said that depressed people
have an imbalance of serotonin production. There is some evidence that
when a person is exposed to long-term anxiety, stress hormones such as
cortisol interfere with the synthesis of serotonin.1
Teenage depression is also due to this defect and could be responsible
for the development of addiction. Thus we need to look at brain chemistry.
A neurotransmitter is a chemical substance produced by the body
that bridges the gap between one neuron (nerve cell) and another. Tiny
electrical currents are transmitted from one neuron to another via a gap
or synapse when it is occupied by a specific neurotransmitter.
It is at this junction which permits the triggering of electric current
in the next cell depending on the neurotransmitter at the synapse. Thus
neurotransmitters may be seen as some sort of regulators. Neurotransmitters
are stored in the nerve cells vesicles and are released
from these cells. They lock on to special receptors of the next nerve
cells, very much like a key fitting into a lock. Each receptor is unique
to a neurotransmitter.
There are many neurotransmitters but let us concentrate on serotonin.
Serotonin - also known as 5-hydroxytryptamine - is a compound widely distributed
in tissues, particularly in blood platelets, intestinal wall and the central
nervous system.2 As a brain neurotransmitter
it helps us to relax, enjoy life and promotes sleeping (when it is converted
to another neurotransmitter called melatonin released by the pituitary
gland during darkness).
Like many other neurotransmitters, serotonin is produced from proteins
in food. These proteins are broken down during the process of digestion
into small units of proteins or building blocks, called amino acids. There
are only about twenty amino acids from which the body builds new proteins
necessary for growth and reconstruction of tissues. Of the twenty amino
acids or so, ten are essential, which means that the body cannot synthesize
them and must obtain these from food.3
Serotonin is produced from an essential amino acid called tryptophan.
Soya, brown rice, cottage cheese, fish, beef, liver, lamb, peanuts, milk
and bananas are rich in tryptophan. If you would like to find out more
about sources of nutrients please look up the file Rich Sources
of Nutrients under articles.
The metabolic processes in the body are driven along by enzymes (or catalysts)
- themselves proteins - converting one substance to another without altering
the enzymes themselves. These operate with co-enzymes, such as vitamins
and minerals, without which these enzymes cannot function efficiently.
Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxine) is required to convert tryptophan into serotonin.
Additional magnesium also helps. Thus when we have a vitamin B6 deficiency
- often the case with people who have high levels of toxins in their body
- then tryptophan is not converted to serotonin 4
. Some signs are depression and insomnia.5
Tryptophan can also be converted to vitamin B3 (niacin) under the influence
of B6 (pyridoxine). This takes precedence over serotonin production.6
This could explain why in some cases of mental illness vitamin B3 supplementation
has improved the condition.
The absorption of amino acids follows a pecking order; the absorption
of phenylalanine (an other essential amino acids and we will come back
to this later) comes before the absorption of tryptophan. They compete
with one another for absorption.
Why sugar addiction?
One way to speed up the absorption of tryptophan is by consuming
refined carbohydrates - such as sugar. Sugar consumption triggers the
body to produce insulin, a hormone that transports glucose, amino acids
and fatty acids into cells. Thus high levels of insulin absorb amino acids
(as well as glucose) and make room for the absorption of tryptophan.7
This is then converted to serotonin in the presence of vitamin B6 and
presto we feel happy!!!
This may lead to sugar addiction and here is theory connecting hypoglycemia
and addiction. Sucrophilia or love of sugar is one of the
symptoms of hypoglycemia.
The question remains how this can lead to other forms of addictions such
as addiction to heroin or cocaine.
Insulin Resistance follows
Sugar addiction leads eventually to insulin resistance. When the body
is exposed to excess insulin over a long period of time, it adapts by
down-regulating receptors for this hormone. This means reducing
insulin receptors in target cells.
Insulin Resistance is an abnormal response of the cells receptors
to insulin. Both hypoglycemia and diabetes are affected by insulin
resistance. In diabetes insulin resistance results in hyperglycaemia,
responsible for increase in atherosclerosis, changes in the retina of
the eye and cataract, changes in kidney which lead to protein excretion
via the urine8, damage to nervous
system, particularly of the legs producing tingling and numbness.
In hypoglycemia it initially raises the blood sugar level, which triggers
the production of more insulin. This is then followed by a crash in blood
sugar level. When blood sugar levels crash the brain goes into a panic
mode and triggers the adrenal gland to produce adrenaline. The latter
converts stored glucose - in the form of glycogen in liver cells - back
into glucose. But adrenaline is also the fight/flight hormone, which prepares
the body for action. Excess secretion of adrenaline may lead to the shakes
and nerves!!
Thus people may have learned that depressant drugs - particularly alcohol
and tranquilisers - can calm down nerves, and here we have another mechanism
for addiction to depressant drugs!
Insulin Resistance may block phenylalanine?
But there is another important theory that may explain the heroin/cocaine
addiction. Hyperinsulinism means that other amino acids are blocked for
absorption. Thus it could well be that phenylalanine - an other essential
amino acid - is not properly absorbed, because of insulin resistance.
Phenylalanine is the forerunner of a series of neurotransmitters - called
catecholamines - among these the important neurotransmitter dopamine.
Dopamine is the main neurotransmitter responsible for the highs that drug
addicts experience when injecting with heroin, or taking cocaine.
Special brain cells produce dopamine (from a long series of biochemical
conversions deriving from phenylalanine), a neurotransmitter responsible
for feelings of pleasure. Normally dopamine is reabsorbed by the dopamine
cell for reuse. It is known that heroine and cocaine occupy these receptors
for dopamine so that reuptake of dopamine is prevented. This results in
an excess of dopamine, which drug addicts experience as a high. However,
the brain - in other words target cells responding to dopamine - respond
by down-regulating receptors as a defence against excess dopamine. Thus
down-regulation of receptors is the mechanism whereby tolerance
is build up. More of the substance - heroin or cocaine - is required to
experience the high! Consequently, the body has to rely on drugs in order
to obtain sufficient levels of dopamine for a person to function at all.
GABA cells control dopamine cells
Another set of brain cells, namely GABA (gamma-amino-butyric-acid) cells,
regulate the production of dopamine in dopamine cells. GABA is an inhibitory
neurotransmitter that sends messages to dopamine cells and controls the
amount of dopamine these cells produce. Thus it exerts influence over
the dose of dopamine release. What may be useful to know at this stage
is, that GABA is produced from glutamine (a non-essential amino acid)
and converted to GABA in the presence of vitamin B6. (Chaitow, 79) A supplement
of glutamine (easily converted to glutamic acid9)
is now available from health food stores. Glutamine has been successfully
used in stopping alcohol and sugar craving and may be helpful in the treatment
of other drug addictions.
Theories about the causes of drug addiction
The question is whether drug addiction is primarily due to an error in
serotonin synthesis or results from hypoglycemia? This question is similar
to the nature-nurture debate in psychology. We have seen that we could
reason that a blockage of serotonin production, would lead to depression,
to sugar addiction, which in turn leads to insulin resistance, diabetes
and/or drug addiction. No doubt there are genetic factors operating that
predispose us towards either or all of these conditions. If we accept
the serotonin hypothesis, being seen primarily as an inherited condition,
then we would come to a dead end. This would be a form of biological determinism,
presenting us with an inevitable outcome of our congenital destiny - a
rather pessimistic point of view.
If on the other hand we were to accept that hypoglycemia, a lifestyle
condition, precedes or aggravates an inherited weak link in serotonin
metabolism, then this would open the way to new treatments and interventions
for either depression, hypoglycemia, diabetes or drug addiction.
The serotonin hypothesis would suggest that it is a mere coincidence that
in the twentieth century humans have been increasing their sugar consumption
on average 15 lbs per head per year in 1900 to 120 lbs per head per year
in 1974. (Cheraskin, 8) In the year 2001 this figure would
be much higher! Furthermore, humans are now exposed to 65,000 xenobiotic
(often poisonous) chemicals produced in the USA alone (1000 chemicals
added each year) and dumped in the environment and undermining our health.
As a result of modern agricultural practice in the USA trace mineral deficiencies
in the soil were reported in all fifty states, zinc deficiency in 32 states.
This means that an important co-enzyme like zinc may be in short supply
in the diet - 80 enzymes are known to require zinc as a co-enzyme. It
is no coincidence that alcoholics or anorectic patients are known to be
zinc deficient. The evidence of drastic environmental changes during the
last few decades, which would decisively affect our health, cannot be
ignored.
It would be more reasonable to assume that the nutritional environment
of modern humans plays a more significant role in the pandemic of mental
illness, hypoglycemia, diabetes and drug addiction. The inherited error
of serotonin metabolism appears to be of secondary importance.
The conclusion would be that dietary treatment is significant in any treatment
modality for addiction and in particular the treatment of hypoglycemia,
which appears to be at the root of all these modern diseases. The finger
is pointed to sugar consumption.10
Alternative treatment of drug addiction
Most modalities in the treatment of drug addiction start with detoxification.
This is probably the most difficult step in treatment. Not only that,
but staying off is even more difficult. The reason is clear that the brain
has adapted to the use of high levels of dopamine, artificially increased
by drugs and resulting in a reduction of receptors for dopamine (and perhaps
other neurotransmitters). It will take some time for the brain to readapt
(that is build receptors) for the neurotransmitters now synthesized naturally.
Thus to expect that the natural production of neurotransmitters (for instance
dopamine) will find adequate receptors - now reduced by drug use - may
indeed be a tall order.
This scenario applies equally to the prescription of Selective Serotonin
Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs) by doctors for the treatment of depression.
These, like street drugs, block the reabsorption of a neurotransmitter,
serotonin. Long term use may alter the brain structure - down regulates
receptors for serotonin. Hence withdrawal often results in rebound depression.
You can only withdraw from these drugs gradually and under the supervision
of the doctor. If this is so, why not the same for street drugs?
I am just wondering in the light of the above knowledge, whether it would
be possible for drug addicts to eventually reach a point, where drugs
are not needed, if and when they would treat the underlying causes of
drug addiction. This could be achieved by adopting hypoglycemic diet,
take suitable vitamins and minerals11
, and neurotransmitter supplements such as tryptophan, phenylalanine and
glutamine UNDER THE SUPERVISION of a doctor or drug counsellor (phenylalanine
may have adverse effects in some people). This suggests a reversal in
the official treatment process, deal with underlying causes first, before
withdrawing from drugs. This may be a radical view, especially because
there appear to be no studies to support this hypothesis.
Many more studies will be required to clarify some of the points raised
here. It is expected that clinical nutritionists will contribute further
to this research.
As we have noted the sequence leading to addiction following the error
in serotonin synthesis may be triggered by a long period of emotional
stress responsible for the imbalance in brain chemicals. Therefore, it
cannot be stressed enough, that this regime should be accompanied with
a course in psychotherapy or Rational Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (RCBT),
which will help a person to deal with the normal stresses of life. Drug
addicts - and for that matter others suffering from a mental disorder
- have a severely damaged self image which affects their personality at
the core. This can be remedied by doing a course in psychotherapy. Such
a self-help course is freely available at this web site at PSYCHOTHERAPY.
References to addiction and hypoglycemia
Burton Goldberg Group, The, Strohecker, J (Ed) (1994), ALTERNATIVE
MEDICINE: The definitive guide, Future Medicine Publishing, Puyallup
WA
Chaitow,L(1985), AMINO ACIDS IN THERAPY, Thorsons Pub. Inc N.Y.
Wade, C (1985), AMINO ACIDS BOOK, Keats Pub Inc, New Canaan, Conn.
1 ) Strickland PL, Deakin JF, Percival
C, Dixon J, Gater RA, Goldberg DP. Bio-social origins of depression in
the community. Interactions between social adversity, cortisol and serotonin
neurotransmission. Br J Psychiatry. 2002 Feb;180:168-73.
2 ) The sudden contraction of smooth
muscle in brain capillaries is one of the factors involved in the development
of migraine headaches. Serotonin is thought to play a role
in inflammation similar to that of histamine.
3) These are arginine, histidine,
isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine, tryptophan
and valine.
4 ) When there is a vitamin B6 deficiency,
tryptophan is converted to xanthurenic acid and excreted in the urine.
Xanthurenic acid may damage the pancreas and may cause diabetes. It is
also a carcinogenic substance. Xanthurenic acid in the urine indicates
a vitamin B6 deficiency. There is anecdotal evidence that B6 deficiency
is indicated when people cannot remember their dreams, as is common among
drug addicts. This is thought to be due to B6 being used up in detoxification.
5 ) Doctors prescribe antidepressant
drugs, called Specific Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs) to artificially
increase serotonin levels in depression.
6 ) It takes 60mg of tryptophan to
produce 1mg of niacin, which also requires vitamin B6 as coenzyme. (Chaitow,
p65)
7 ) Plasma tyrosine, phenylalanine,
leucine, isoleucine and valine, being large neutral amino acids - unlike
tryptophan - are affected by insulin and are consequently absorbed, leaving
free the absorption of tryptophan.
8 ) This supports the concept of insulin
resistance failing to absorb amino acids (including phenylalanine) by
cells, which are then excreted in the urine, along with glucose, typical
in diabetes.
9 ) Glutamic acid is a brain fuel.
It cannot pass the blood brain barrier, but it is easily converted to
glutamine, which can. When glutamic acid combines with ammonia - a nitrogenous
by-product of amino acids and toxic to the brain - it becomes glutamine.
Ammonia is then converted to urea and excreted via the urine. Glutamine
is said to improve intelligence, control alcoholism, sugar craving, heal
ulcers, alleviate fatigue, impotence, depression, and may be useful in
schizophrenia and senility.
10 ) Just recently it has been announced
that the consumption of kola soft drinks - the popular high
sugar drinks of young people - has been increased by 7 per cent in the
last six months of the year 2001. The fact that they may contain aspartame
may aggravate the impact on their behaviour.
11 ) Some of the vitamins and minerals
suggested are, Vitamin C (up to tolerance level +/- 3000 mg (Drug addicts
can tolerate high doses of vitamin C), zinc, chromium (picolinate), selenium,
B-Complex, vitamin B6, B12, folate and herbals supporting the liver: Dandelion,
St Marys Thistle, Gentian, Fringe Tree, Greater Celandine, Withania
(for anxiety) and many more.
|
|
Website disclaimer
Articles index
Back to main |